My ignorance about the bigger world of motorized road-bound vehicles notwithstanding, somehow I still end up building a lot of car models. Whether it’s the Speed Champions or some random truck or van from another series, I all too often find myself attracted to some of them. Not necessarily for them as “cars being cars”, funny enough, though. Sometimes I just like the design and idea behind it, other times my zeal for harvesting parts just gets in the way and yet another time it’s just an affordable way to kill some time on an evening with a manageable number of pieces. The two cars presented here are inevitably a mix of all these things, so let’s have a look.
Price and Contents
But first things first and let’s run our usual drill of evaluating the price and value. At 194 pieces for 20 Euro the Penguin Slushy Van (60384) is the cheaper of the two models. It regularly retails around 13 Euro, however, so it is extremely affordable. The downside to that is that it feels rather barebones, with only the two minifigures and no other extras. That also goes for the van itself, which could be summarized as “you just don’t see where those 200 parts are”. A lot of them are simply buried inside and/ or invisibly used on the chassis. At this price there’s little point to complain about that, though.
The second package, the Dog Rescue Van (41741) likewise comes with pretty exactly 200 pieces, but at 30 Euro is a tenner more costly. Whether that can be attributed to a few more larger parts and them being a different kind or LEGO just deciding on prices randomly during lunch break is anyone’s guess, of course. It feels a bit arbitrary and you just can’t see where those extra bucks go. The vehicles end up being about the same size and what little additional effort and parts the little side build may require surely doesn’t rationalize the extra cost. This would be expensive if it cost 25 Euro and the self-regulating magic of the market seems to prove my point. Apparently nobody buys this at full price, so retailers offer it regularly for 18 Euro or less to their own financial detriment.
Penguin Slushy Van (60384)
Right out of the gate the slushy van is one of those “I get the idea, but…” situations. You can see the intention of what the designers tried to do, but at the same time you also see the simplifications and where corners were cut. One of the most obvious issues to me is the color scheme, meaning more specifically some choices in the actual colors used vs. ones that would have been desirable.
The thing that bugs me the most are the mud guards. Apparently LEGO were unwilling/ it wasn’t in the budget to produce this particular type of wheel housing in Orange, considering they haven’t done so in 15 years and even then only once. As it is, we end up with the Dark Azure version again, but really, who needs that? In recent years they clearly have used this version way too often. The point here is not so much me bitching about this just to make a stir, but Orange would have much better served to communicate the idea of this being a penguin sliding on its belly. You know, those feet… In fact perhaps there should even have been two colors with the front being Black to hint at the wings and the aft being the Orange ones for the flippers. Either way, it feels like some very obvious visual trick was missed here.
The other issue pertaining to the colors is that the vehicle feels neither frosty nor refreshing. The other blue-ish areas are the wrong kinds of blue, the Black regions are too extensive and even the Magenta trim elements make things look kind of dirty and depressing. Point in case: This is nothing I would suspect being a slushy van/ ice cream vendor if it drove around the neighborhood ringing its bells. The stickers would not improve this too much, either.
Another such weak point is the slushy cup on the roof, even more so since it isn’t meant to receive a sticker that would act as the branding/ label. It looks a bit weird and not at all like a bottle filled with fluid. Again it also doesn’t look “frosty” nor does it convey the frothy/ foamy texture of the liquid. Even if they hadn’t changed anything else, making the two half-cylinders Trans Orange or Trans Red would already have improved things and communicated this better.
Coming beg to that penguin thing, the front doesn’t really do it for me, either. I guess the most obvious shortcoming is the “beak” not really looking very pointy and the face being to compressed. Those eyes should be further up and on a real van of this ilk would probably be stickers on the hood. that doesn’t mean this section is bad, just not really what I would do. On the bright side it does come with the (for now) still somewhat rare rounded corner piece in Black and the semi-circular 1 x 2 tile in the same color.
The interior is functional, but not very exciting and rather sparse. With so little on offer it is questionable whether the business would be sustainable. Not even a fridge to keep the base juices/ syrup around! Of course the penguin costume minifigure is one of the highlights of this set, though similar to the car itself I feel a color other than Dark Azure would have popped more. How about Bright Light Blue or Light Aqua?
While my complaints may sound terrible, in summary this is a good enough van in the sense of “generic food van No. 5” It would work for a number of scenarios with minor changes, it just doesn’t do the job it was originally designed for very well. Just a dab of Orange here and there would have made it look more friendly. Similarly, making it entirely Black and adding some gold trim could sell this as a gourmet BBQ or cheese wagon. there’s a lot of ways to spin this.
LEGO Friends, Dog Rescue Van (41741)
The second van comes from a different universe, in a manner of speaking, and it definitely shows with regards to the way it is constructed, color selection and so on. Before we delve into that, let’s have a look at the side build, though.
This set comes with a little bus stop. It’s not realistic in that it lacks the typical parking bay and is built directly onto the lawn rather than connecting with the road. To me this is more like one of those auxiliary stops in big parks or cemeteries that are only serviced during certain hours of the day or on weekends with small (electrical) vehicles while the rest of the time people would simply us it as a normal bench for resting. If you buy into this backstory then the little contraption makes sense. What doesn’t make sense is how flimsy it is and I really wish there was a bit more going on to stabilize the two Lavender frames in particular. The “found dog” kennel with the raise-able sign to signify people whether it’s occupied is a nice idea, though I’m not sure how it would work in practice and haven’t seen it anywhere near me. You know, someone would still need to alert the nearest animal shelter or authorities by phone or whatever.
On to the car that in this scenario apparently would be the means of picking up the stray dog(s) and provide first care. What drew me in here was the containerized design, a concept which has rarely been explored in the Friends line or for that matter in other series as well, at least for cars of this size. You may get your occasional explorer truck with a removable lab or similar, but for those smaller vans it’s not as common. In this particular case you could sell it as a custom build on top of a used car frame perhaps and that’s why it looks a bit wacky in a way with the container being noticeably wider than the car’s frame.
On that note: The van definitely needed to be longer. Even just adding two studs would have improved the appearance massively and it might also have helped adding some more stuff to the interior. Short bed vans do exist, yes, but with the curved panels taking up so much space it doesn’t look very elegant. For me as a parts collector of sorts the 2 x 2 quarter cylinders in Bright Light Yellow do have some value, though, as it’s a new color not seen before.
The stubby-ness is also very noticeable in the front view with the truck looking like it was cut off in the wrong place. This can be verified further once you take off the removable sub-assemblies. The car’s usable length is literally split in half with fifty percent being allocated to the cabin and the other fifty to the container. This also explains why it looks so disproportionate. In artsy terms it would need to be more along the lines of the Golden Ratio with the rear bed being extended ever so slightly. The images at least illustrate that everything is very accessible, so decent play value is ensured.
Not to belabor my point about the length ad nauseam, but the inside of the container could serve as further indication that more space wouldn’t have been a bad idea. It feels very crammed and doesn’t even come with a transport unit for whatever dog they may pick up. I also think it would be more realistic if there were actual stilts/ supports to raise the container into a convenient working position.
For the figures we have Dr. Marlon and another version of Nova along with her dog. The girl has a different shirt and the dog comes with its harness in Sand Blue as opposed to the Neon Yellow in the other set. Regrettably there is no additional dog that would actually fit into the little rescue kennel at the bus stop. It would have enhanced the play fantasy quite a bit.
Outside that the set does not offer anything special or exciting, unfortunately. The idea behind it just doesn’t feel fleshed out enough and for all intents and purposes this perhaps should have been part of a larger set with an actual rescue station. That would have allowed to “sell” things differently. Some might argue that I should just shut up and buy the actual Dog Rescue Center (41727), but that doesn’t really do it for me, either. Something just doesn’t gel. That aside, it simply strikes me as an odd sales strategy.
Concluding Thoughts
A lot of what I wrote no doubt sounds like I’m unhappy, but ultimately I’m not. With those sets I didn’t expect anything magical to happen and within the constraints and limitations of these series and the cost of the models even the designers can only do so much. It’s more about seeing the potential of what could have been. That said, there’s of course nothing wrong with these sets. With some modifications the slushy van would be a good addition to many City scenes and the same could be said over on the other side in Heartlake City. On their own they just feel a little incomplete and of limited use.